Joe Manganiello, 36
Before Henry Cavill locked down the role of Superman, this True Blood star was neck-and-neck with him during the casting process. So, Snyder already likes him, and that could give him an edge for Batman. He has the chiseled features down pat, and he’s built like an ox, but the jury is still out on if he has the darkness to play the Dark Knight. But, he does have the chin for it, and that goes a long way.